Key takeaways

• Increased espresso costs don’t robotically incentivise funding in espresso high quality.
• Market volatility will increase monetary danger, making it tougher for producers to foretell revenue and plan forward.
• Merchants, roasters, and shoppers are additionally value delicate and can typically commerce down.
• Lengthy-term stability, not short-term value spikes, greatest helps espresso high quality.

Increased espresso costs are sometimes assumed to be excellent news for high quality. The logic appears easy: if producers obtain more cash, they need to have the ability to make investments extra in farming, processing, and high quality enchancment. 

However in actuality, greater costs don’t result in constantly higher-quality espresso – and in some circumstances, they might scale back the inducement to develop it. It is because when market costs rise sharply, producers can earn stronger returns by promoting undifferentiated espresso with out incurring the additional prices and dangers related to specialty espresso manufacturing.

On the similar time, roasters and merchants going through greater prices typically scale back high quality necessities to handle margins and shield shopper demand. The result’s a market the place value will increase are pushed by shortage and volatility reasonably than high quality funding.

This dynamic turned more and more obvious when arabica costs surged to report ranges in early 2025. Though they’ve since declined and stabilised, ongoing US-Latin American political pressure and improved climate outlook in Brazil might drive them greater once more.

You may additionally like our article on how report espresso costs don’t essentially make producers value makers.

Worth volatility creates extra danger for producers

One of many main challenges posed by greater espresso costs is volatility. For espresso producers, this makes revenue unpredictable and monetary planning extraordinarily tough.

“In August 2025, the value variance between the very best and lowest factors inside the month was 40%,” says Jorge Cuevas, Chief Espresso Officer at Sustainable Harvest Espresso. “Think about making an attempt to run the household price range, not to mention the enterprise of rising espresso, when your revenue can range by as much as 40% in a single month.”

Timing additionally issues. Espresso is usually bought from farmers months earlier than export contracts are finalised. Throughout that window, international costs and overseas change charges can shift dramatically.

“Christopher Feran lately identified that cherry value and FX charge should even be thought of. In Ethiopia final yr, for instance, espresso cherries had been bought from October to January, whereas contracts had been registered from December to March,” explains Kosta Kallivrousis, Senior Provide Chain Advisor at Age of Espresso. “The distinction between these two time durations is sort of US$2/lb. The FX charge misplaced worth over this time interval, making the quantity paid to farmers even much less.”

On the similar time, manufacturing prices are rising. Fertiliser costs have risen, labour shortages persist, and local weather volatility has made espresso manufacturing dearer and dangerous. In lots of areas, greater farmgate costs are largely offset by these rising prices.

Why excessive costs can scale back high quality incentives

Producing high-quality espresso requires further labour, time, and infrastructure. Selective harvesting and cautious processing each contain greater danger and upfront funding.

Traditionally, producers have pursued high quality differentiation when commodity costs had been low.

“The overwhelming majority of espresso farmers look to differentiated markets as a method to escape espresso pricing that received’t pay above the price of manufacturing,” Kosta explains.

So when market costs are excessive, that incentive typically disappears. Producers can earn robust returns by rapidly promoting commercial-grade espresso, with out the uncertainty related to experimental processing and micro heaps.

When producers count on costs to fall once more, many prioritise short-term monetary safety over long-term funding. “They give the impression of being to money in rapidly as a result of they know, traditionally, a interval of upper costs received’t final lengthy,” Kosta provides. “Satirically, a high-priced market is traditionally horrible for incentivising and supporting high quality espresso.”

Excessive costs additionally affect purchaser behaviour. Specialty inexperienced espresso merchants and roasters, going through greater baseline prices, are more and more cautious about paying further premiums.

“Since costs are so excessive, some specialty consumers are reducing their high quality expectations,” says Neil Oney, Inexperienced Espresso High quality Supervisor at StoneX Espresso. “Many, however not all, are much less more likely to spend further on micro heaps once they’re spending micro lot costs on blenders.”

Shopper behaviour adjustments, too. Knowledge signifies that when the C market is excessive, and roasters increase their costs, shoppers have a tendency to buy lower-quality espresso. 

Kosta additionally cites the instance of commerce costs in the course of the pandemic. The Sustainable Espresso Transaction Information reported a 20% lower in higher-quality specialty coffees (84+ factors) and a 17% enhance in common specialty coffees (80-83 factors).

When commercial-grade coffees can promote for over US$4lb – much like what specialty-grade micro heaps achieved in some markets solely a yr earlier – the monetary reward for producing distinctive espresso turns into marginal. This shift dangers flattening high quality differentiation throughout the market.

Looking for stability and long-term options

The C value has fallen from report highs in current weeks. illycaffè predicts that it’s going to stabilise between US$2.80 and US$3/lb within the second half of 2026, though this stays above the common of the previous 5 years.

Rabobank additionally stories that political instability between the US and South America might push costs greater. The current US army operation in Venezuela has drawn criticism from Brazilian President Lula and Colombian President Petro, which might disrupt espresso commerce between the international locations. The reinstatement of tariffs, together with the earlier 50% on Brazil, may very well be disastrous.

With costs anticipated to stay unstable within the foreseeable future, many argue that stability, not short-term positive aspects, must be the precedence. Longer-term contracts, relationship-based sourcing, and clear discussions of manufacturing prices are more and more seen as methods to cut back provide chain danger.

“This requires sincere conversations about what advantages every social gathering. It requires listening to what individuals need versus what they want,” Kosta explains. “Producers’ and roasters’ realities is likely to be worlds aside, however are united via espresso. Having versatile, long-term commitments is one method to mitigate the crushing volatility everyone seems to be experiencing. It may well steadiness the highs and lows skilled, reasonably than capitalising on one another’s unlucky circumstances. 

“The good information concerning the specialty espresso commerce is that we will make up totally different guidelines if we would like.”

Higher alignment amongst producers, merchants, and roasters might assist easy volatility, shield high quality, and be certain that greater costs translate into sustainable outcomes reasonably than short-lived windfalls.

“Open communication and engagement throughout the availability chain is vital,” Jorge says. “Understanding the price of manufacturing and collectively working in direction of reflecting the correct worth for every espresso is paramount.”

There are additionally requires consumers to imagine higher danger, notably when requesting experimentally processed coffees or micro heaps. Committing to buy these coffees, even when outcomes are unsure, might assist restore incentives for high-quality growth.

“Purchase them even when they don’t end up as anticipated,” Neil says. “Producers take plenty of danger with experimental processing, they usually shouldn’t should when it’s your product and at your request.”

The specialty espresso business has lengthy positioned itself as distinct from the commodity market, constructed on high quality, transparency, and shared worth. Sustained excessive costs threaten to blur that divide.

Increased costs alone received’t assure higher espresso. With out coordinated approaches that steadiness danger, reward, and funding in high quality, the market can drift towards standardisation.

Loved this? Then learn our article on what’s subsequent after excessive espresso costs.

Picture credit: Sustainable Harvest

Good Each day Grind

Need to learn extra articles like this? Join our e-newsletter!