The U.S. Meals and Drug Administration (FDA) has closed a reopened public remark interval on a food-additive petition that might have an effect on the continued use of methylene chloride in espresso decaffeination.

The renewed remark interval, which closed June 29, invited new data on a 2.5-year-old petition in search of to take away food-additive authorizations for 4 solvents: benzene, ethylene dichloride, methylene chloride and trichloroethylene.

For the espresso business, the important thing substance is methylene chloride, a chemical solvent utilized in some business espresso decaffeination, usually described because the “European technique.” The chemical is at the moment monitored by the FDA by means of residue limits of 10 elements per million in decaffeinated roasted espresso and decaffeinated soluble espresso extract.

The petition was filed in December 2023 by a coalition of client advocacy teams together with the Environmental Protection Fund, Breast Most cancers Prevention Companions, the Middle for Environmental Well being and the Environmental Working Group, and particular person Lisa Lefferts.

The petitioners argue that the solvents have been discovered to induce most cancers in people or animals and subsequently can’t legally stay approved as meals components below the Delaney Clause, a provision of federal legislation barring carcinogenic meals components.

In a January 2024 announcement, EDF Senior Director for Chemical substances Coverage Maria Doa stated, “FDA has been disregarding the legislation by allowing these long-established carcinogens to be added to meals.”

Some espresso firms say they’ve moved away from methylene chloride in decaf sourcing or advertising. But the U.S. espresso business’s most lively commerce group has pushed again in opposition to the petition, arguing that methylene-chloride decaf is secure below present limits and {that a} ban would needlessly limit client entry.

The Nationwide Espresso Affiliation stated roughly 10% of U.S. adults, or about 26 million folks, drink decaf every day, and that the majority decaf espresso is produced utilizing the European Technique. “Banning European Technique decaf would defy science and hurt Individuals’ well being,” NCA President and CEO Invoice Murray stated in a March 2024 assertion.

The group has additionally characterised the teams in search of restrictions as “activist teams recognized for utilizing scare ways to frighten Individuals in regards to the security of on a regular basis meals.”

When the FDA reopened the remark interval on the docket, it particularly requested for “sensible concerns” for producers in “phasing out impacted makes use of” ought to the company partially or absolutely grant the petition.

The company has not but introduced a call. 

Feedback? Questions? Information to share? Contact DCN’s editors right here. For all the most recent espresso business information, subscribe to the DCN publication.