Rather a lot can go incorrect with pecan pie. In case you do it proper, it may be the crown of your Thanksgiving desk: a crackly sugar prime hovering over meaty pecans suspended in a comfortable, gooey brown sugar filling. However when performed poorly, it may be a sticky, cloying mess of corn syrup and nuts, barely set atop a soggy backside. To keep away from disappointment, I’ve taken to creating a pecan chocolate galette—not simply through the autumn, however all yr lengthy.

The galette is the easy-going, freeform, European cousin of American pie. With a galette, you don’t have to persuade your dough right into a dish or drive it to maintain its edges primly poised on the lip of a pie plate. When you’ve rolled out your dough, you simply must fill, fold, and go. If the form is a little bit wonky, you possibly can simply chalk it as much as its rustic attraction. 

Because the depth of a galette will at all times be considerably shorter than that of a pie, the required baking time is shorter as effectively. Whereas a pecan pie can take an hour or extra to bake within the oven, a pecan galette wants solely half that point to cook dinner, and means the cooling time is drastically decreased as effectively. Faster, simpler, and fewer painstaking throughout? I can get behind that. 

The Greatest Chocolate to Use

I’m a real darkish chocolate lover, however for due diligence, I examined this galette with a number of completely different candies: semisweet chocolate chips, 72% cacao chocolate chips, unsweetened chocolate chips, unsweetened baker’s chocolate bars, milk chocolate bars, and darkish chocolate bars. 

Mixed with the corn syrup and brown sugar filling, the milk and semisweet candies proved far too candy, and the caramel notes from low cacao proportion candies fought with brown sugar’s molasses notes, producing a bitter conflict of flavors. On the opposite excessive, unsweetened chocolate supplied nice depth of taste with out including sweetness, however was astringent and unsightly to eat. In a single check, I made the filling by melting unsweetened chocolate with the butter and sweeteners. It was by far the worst galette I made: It smothered the flavour of the pecans and lacked the comfortable, barely chewy texture I needed.

The 72% chocolate was delightfully darkish with out being too bitter, however didn’t incorporate effectively into the filling and left it studded with chips as an alternative of the chocolate-scented pecan pie filling I used to be in search of. Fortunately, finely chopping  high-quality chocolate and mixing it with the chopped nuts earlier than including the liquid filling solved the chocolate riddle. (I attempted and appreciated chocolate starting from 55 to 72% cacao; above that, the chocolate produced a filling that was too bitter.)

Getting the Filling Proper

I’d already pulled a quick one on the type of the pie, and wasn’t about to mess with the center as effectively. I fiddled with the ratios of the core components of pecan pie (butter, corn syrup, brown sugar, eggs, vanilla, and salt) till I acquired a combination with a balanced sweetness that baked up comfortable on the within with a barely crackly prime. The variations I made with entire eggs have been puffing up irregularly and forcefully towards the start of baking, making the filling leap up and over the sting of the tart. Utilizing simply yolks solved this downside: whereas there was nonetheless some puff, it occurred later within the baking course of and didn’t trigger the filling to spill over the sides. I additionally added some flour to stiffen up the filling sufficient to allow it to mound within the middle. This manner, you possibly can simply fold the dough border up and over the filling with out it working off. 

The crust is the true make-or-break behind an ideal pie, and this, too, holds true with galettes. A lot has already been stated on tips on how to make a nice pie crust; there’s not way more I can add to that dialog. I’m in a deeply dedicated relationship with Stella Park’s Previous-Common All-Butter Pie Crust recipe, and when you give it a strive, I’m positive you’ll be, too.