by Chris Arnold
For a very long time, the Technivorm Espresso Maker reigned just about king for the espresso geek who needed a semi-automatic drip brewer. It brewed on the proper temp for the correct amount of time, had even saturation of the grounds, a thermal carafe, and was constructed like a tank. It was made within the Netherlands, and it was costly. Like virtually $300 USD costly.
I owned a Technivorm Moccamaster Thermal for a number of years and ended up eliminating it in favor of one thing that was plumbed in, the Newco OCS-8, which I nonetheless need to today. The Newco was one of many solely different SCAA-approved brewers on the time. In any case, I not have the Technivorm to match to the Bonavita aspect by aspect, however I’ve a few years of fond reminiscences and scrumptious cups of espresso.
Not too way back, Bonavita got here out with a really comparable brewer, at roughly half the value. Many referred to as it the “Technivorm Killer”. So at roughly $150, can the Bonavita Espresso Maker stand as much as the $300 Technivorm?
NOTE: Each Bonavita and Technivorm make scorching plate fashions with glass carafes, however we aren’t going to cowl these. In any case, cooking your espresso is nearly a white-collar crime, to not point out an enormous electrical energy draw.
Construct High quality
The Bonavita construct high quality is certainly inferior to the Technivorm. The Bonavita feels just a little low-cost and plasticky in locations, whereas the Technivorm may be very strong with an all-aluminum physique. Most variations are beauty, however the one inside distinction is the copper heating ingredient of the Technivorm, which presumably heats the water extra effectively and should last more. As you will notice under, it doesn’t appear to have an effect on the temperature, so take it with a grain of salt. The Technivorm is produced within the Netherlands and designed by a Dutch firm. The Bonavita is produced in China and designed by a German firm.
Thermal Carafe
The Bonavita 1.25 liter stainless carafe is glass-lined, holds temps very well, and the pour spout doesn’t drip a lot in any respect. The carafe has a lid that seals fairly properly. Nonetheless, you could take away the lid to position the cone filter basket for brewing, after which take away the filter basket and put the lid again on. Form of a ache. To pour, you could press a properly positioned lever.
NOTE: Bonavita does promote a mannequin that isn’t glass-lined however seems virtually equivalent. Be sure to get mannequin BV1800TH, which has a glass-lined carafe.
The Technivorm 1.25 liter stainless carafe doesn’t require levers or unscrewing to pour. You simply pour. Nonetheless, it was not the most effective. I ditched it for two causes: It gave off a definite steel style, and the pour spout dripped like loopy. I perceive a few of the included carafes are higher now. I changed the inventory carafe with a Zojirushi Thermal Carafe and customary just a little platform to boost your entire brewer up sufficient for the Zoj to suit below and activate the protection swap. Sadly, you can not do that with the Bonavita, however I don’t assume you’ll want to; it’s lots good. In case you are utilizing the 1 liter Zojirushi, be sure to scale back the quantity of water within the tank. In any other case, it can overfill!
Showerhead
The Bonavita showerhead has an attention-grabbing array of spray holes, and the saturation is sweet and even. However cleansing it may be a little bit of a ache, as grounds finally get embedded in all the little crevices. It’s not unhealthy, however it may possibly take just a little further scrubbing and rinsing.
The Technivorm comes with a “bar” fashion bathe head that saturates properly, although inferior to the Bonavita. However due to the open design, you’ll be able to stir all you need throughout brewing. Once I acquired mine, it got here with a showerhead that had only one gap, however they supplied an upgraded showerhead with a number of holes, which I instantly bought and used for the lifetime of the machine. The multi-hole showerhead made the necessity to stir the grounds a lot much less essential, however generally you do have to get in there and stir. Cleansing is very easy, because the small steel bar simply lifts off, and there aren’t any crevices to fret about. I perceive now that the multi-hole showerhead is commonplace. I used to be capable of finding each Technivorm showerheads in a field someplace, as proven within the photograph under. I can solely guess I purchased spares.
Brew Basket
The Bonavita brew basket is definitely Melitta branded and accepts #4 cone filters. On the Bonavita closed design, if you wish to get in there to stir the grounds throughout brewing, you’ll be able to’t, because the design simply doesn’t enable for it. Due to the extra closed design, it additionally has vent holes to permit steam to flee, reasonably than accumulating and going proper again into the grounds. I’m undecided how a lot this issues within the ultimate consequence, however it’s good to know they considered that.
The Technivorm brew basket accepts #4 cone filters. The Technivorm is an open design with no prime and has a cool little mechanical slider that may limit the circulate out of the underside of the filter basket to be utterly closed, half-open, or full. In order for you, you’ll be able to preserve it closed in the beginning of the brew for 30-60 seconds, then transfer it to midway for one more 30-60 seconds, after which absolutely open for the rest of the cycle. This actually caters to the one that needs to face there and tinker. I at all times left it full open and by no means used that characteristic, however it’s price noting for the nerds on the market.
Water Tank
Not a lot to say right here. They each have see-thru water tanks with markings and easy lids. Simply fill them with water and go.
Energy Swap & Brew Cycle
They each have energy buttons and when pressed, they each start brewing inside about 30-60 seconds. The Bonavita comfortable swap will shut off the machine robotically after quarter-hour, and though the Technivorm will cease the heating parts from consuming energy after the cycle is full, you could shut off the laborious swap manually for it to be really off.
The Technivorm has a intelligent little electro-mechanical security swap that may cease brewing if the carafe is just not in the correct place, positioned down close to the bottom. If utilizing a third social gathering carafe, you might have to style just a little one thing (like just a little piece of froth, and many others.) across the base of the carafe, in order that it correctly engages the swap.
Brew Temperature
Neither of those items has a method to management the temperature. I’ve some previous information from the Technivorm, and the water temps measured instantly within the basket have been proper round 200F-202F (93C-94C). The Bonavita measures proper round 201F-202F (94C). These are in keeping with SCAA requirements, lead to an important cup, and are one much less factor so that you can fear about.
Brew Time
The brew time of each the Bonavita and Technivorm is true round 6 minutes for a full cycle, which is in keeping with SCAA requirements. Once more, one much less factor to futz with.
Style
As a result of I not personal the Technivorm, I couldn’t do a side-by-side style check, however you don’t overlook years of ingesting espresso from a single machine too simply. Each produced excellently and dare I say, comparable cups. The one factor you could do is dial within the grind; all the things else is frequent sense: good water, freshly roasted beans, and a pre-heated carafe.
Misc
Each of those brewers are SCAA-approved.
Each of those machines are saved easy and usually are not uber-geeky fashions just like the Brazen Brewer by Behmor, the place you’ll be able to modify and even calibrate temps for elevation. There’s something refreshing about simplicity carried out proper.
Some Variations to Think about
- The Bonavita is half the price of the Technivorm ($150 vs $300).
- The Bonavita has a semi-closed brewing system, which suggests extra work in day-to-day utilization, longer cleansing, and an incapacity to see or stir the grounds throughout brewing.
- The Technivorm’s open design permits seeing and stirring the grounds, in addition to circulate management. Geeks rejoice!
- The Technivorm’s showerhead is simpler to wash than the Bonavita.
- The Bonavita has a much better carafe proper out of the field. You might have considered trying a third social gathering carafe for the Technivorm to get comparable efficiency.
- The Technivorm is made within the Netherlands (Holland), and the Bonavita in China; if that type of factor issues to you.
- The Technivorm presents a 5-year guarantee, whereas the Bonavita has a 2-year guarantee.
If I used to be simply dipping my toe into the world of higher espresso, I’d advocate that somebody begin with the Bonavita. I believe it accomplishes practically the identical consequence because the Technivorm at half the value. Nonetheless, I’d recommend that for individuals who recognize nice construct high quality, an extended guarantee, or the flexibility to tinker, the Technivorm is a better option, assuming the price range permits for it (and the third social gathering carafe you’ll most likely need to purchase).
Printed on
