by Java Goddess
I’m going to rant and rave slightly bit right here…
One of the simplest ways to guage a espresso roast is with your personal eyes. There is no such thing as a actual uniformity in terminology related to roast colours. Espresso tradition developed concurrently all over the world and no two French Roasts developed with the identical precise darkness. Till not too long ago there has by no means been a definitive chart to say, to what shade or roast diploma, a roast of a sure title should subscribe to.
The Specialty Espresso Affiliation of America (SCAA), in an effort so as to add some uniformity to the trade, has put out a roast shade chart. However that doesn’t have an effect on the model new roaster who is aware of what they used to drink in slightly Cafe in France and begins roasting a medium darkish French Roast, nor does it have an effect on the outdated time family-owned roaster who by no means even heard of the SCAA. If they’ve a espresso that has been their Italian Roast for 50 years, then it doesn’t matter if the correct title of stated roast on the SCAA chart is French or Viennese or Full Metropolis or no matter, it’s nonetheless Italian Roast to them. So the confusion isn’t more likely to dissipate quickly.
This isn’t anybody’s fault and shouldn’t be trigger for consternation. It simply means you’ll have to have a look at the Roasts of your neighborhood espresso joint and work out for your self if their French or their Italian is darker.
Impressions of the Names and the Roasts
A number of the darkest roasts I’ve ever seen are merely burnt, resembling charcoal greater than espresso beans. If the beans are black with no oils on the floor I name it Burnt Roast – it doesn’t matter what the roaster calls it.
Darkest Roasts
The most effective examples of the Darkest Roasts are very shiny and oily and would possibly as effectively be referred to as black in shade. They’re usually referred to as Full Metropolis Roast, Italian Roast, or Viennese Roast (and typically even French Roast). These beans are nearly black and in the event that they go too far (learn – roast too lengthy) they lose the oils utterly and simply appear like burnt carbon, bean-shaped materials (see above). Quite a lot of new roasters let this occur, considering solely that darkish is what’s “in.”

French Roast or Viennese Roast or Full Metropolis Roast
The subsequent stage down is most frequently often called French Roast. With a bean floor that’s oily however much less shiny, the beans are near black however are extra usually an especially darkish brown. In some circles, that is known as a Viennese Roast or a Full Metropolis Roast. Many shoppers wrongfully consider French Roasts to be the darkest out there and in some locations, it’s, so the online of confusion simply will get deeper and deeper.

Medium-Darkish Roasted or Metropolis Roast
A Medium-Darkish Roasted espresso is usually referred to as Metropolis Roast or simply Darkish Roast. These beans are barely oily and darkish brown in shade. This appears to me to be one of many best-tasting roasts, because it has the style of a darkish roast, however isn’t darkish sufficient to have burned away the flavour traits of the actual bean.

Medium Roast
A Medium Roast is a wealthy brown shade, someplace between darkish chocolate and milk chocolate. I’ve additionally seen these referred to as Half Metropolis Roast.

Mild Roast or American Roast or Cinnamon Roast
A Mild Roast is like the colour of Milk Chocolate or lighter. Typically that is referred to as American Roast or Cinnamon Roast. That is the Roast most frequently used for cupping (tasting) espresso samples, the overall consensus being that the darker the Roast the extra of the bean’s style profile that’s misplaced.

I’m not a Roaster, I’m only a choosy coffeehouse proprietor. I exploit 7 totally different Roasters to produce my wants. That’s how I first turned conscious of the disparity between the names and colours of Roasts. It has since turn into slightly sideline examine of mine wherever I am going to notice the variations in Roast title and Roast shade from one cafe to the subsequent.
To do an ample job of roasting espresso one solely wants some inexperienced beans and a roaster. To do a fantastic job, one wants an consciousness of the chemical adjustments the bean goes via, a very good ear to pay attention for the totally different “pops,” and a artistic contact.
Espresso is a science and an artwork. Science is logical, artwork is subjective.
Sources
The Residence Roaster Colour Chart – An 8-color chart of various espresso roast ranges.
Revealed on

