Rooster pot pie at all times hits the spot for me, however let’s be actual, making the crust from scratch isn’t at all times within the playing cards. This soup model offers you all that basic, comfort-food taste with rather less work. It’s wealthy, creamy, filled with tender rooster and veggies, and each chew tastes like rooster soup for the soul.
If you’re up for it, you’ll be able to at all times make an entire rooster pot pie. It’s nonetheless fairly simple.

Why My Recipe
- All of the consolation meals flavors of rooster pot pie in soup type!
- Gnocchi is used as a handy choice to mimic a pie crust, and it is perhaps even higher.
- Made with on a regular basis elements and prepared in below 45 minutes.


A variety of recipes use potatoes for the “pie crust” factor or canned biscuit dough, however that’s simply not my type in any respect. I considered including some home made biscuit dough to behave as dumplings, however a good higher concept got here to thoughts: Gnocchi! These little potato dumplings are offered dry within the pasta aisle in most grocery shops. You get that very same comfortable, doughy “pie crust” goodness, and truthfully, it is perhaps even higher.
Ingredient Notes


- Boneless Skinless Rooster Breast: You’ll want about 1 1/2 kilos. Rooster thighs work too for those who choose darkish meat. Simply trim off any extra fats.
- Olive Oil: Only a bit to brown the rooster. You possibly can sub in avocado oil or any impartial oil you’ve received available.
- Salted Butter: When you solely have unsalted, that’ll work simply fantastic.
- White Onion: A medium onion is ideal right here. Yellow onion works too if that’s what you’ve received.
- Carrots: Use 4 medium carrots. You possibly can cube or slice them, no matter texture you like in your soup.
- Celery Ribs: Go for 4 ribs, sliced.
- All-Objective Flour: This thickens the soup and provides it that creamy pot pie texture. Don’t skip the cooking time, it removes the uncooked flour style.
- Minced Garlic: About 2 tablespoons, which is roughly 6 cloves. Use contemporary if potential, however jarred garlic works too. It simply has a barely extra bitter taste.
- Rooster Broth: Go together with low sodium if you’d like extra management over the salt. Retailer-bought or home made each work nice. I additionally love Higher Than Boullioun.
- Dried Thyme: Only a contact goes a good distance so as to add that signature pot pie taste.
- Heavy Cream: This makes the soup wealthy and silky. You may swap in half-and-half, but it surely received’t be fairly as thick.
- Frozen Peas: Toss them in straight from the freezer. No must thaw. Canned peas will work too, however they’re a lot softer.
- Gnocchi: That is your pie crust stand-in! Search for it within the pasta aisle, sometimes vacuum-packed.
Rotisserie Rooster Shortcut
Rotisserie rooster makes this soup even faster to get on the desk, plus it’s what’s generally known as a “loss chief” which means grocery shops promote it at a loss so it’s the most effective bargains you could find.
You’ll skip the browning step at the start. As an alternative, go forward and begin by sautéing the veggies in butter, then proceed on with the recipe. Stir in about 3 cups of shredded rotisserie rooster when the recipe requires including the cooked rooster again in.
Because the rooster’s already completed, you’ll simply wish to simmer the soup lengthy sufficient to warmth every part by way of and let the flavors come collectively.
Gnocchi Choices
Gnocchi is the key ingredient that offers this soup that “pie crust” vibe with none baking. You’ll normally discover gnocchi in vacuum-sealed packages within the pasta aisle, however refrigerated or frozen gnocchi works too. Shelf-stable gnocchi is tremendous handy and cooks proper within the soup in about 5 minutes.
When you’re utilizing frozen gnocchi, there’s no must thaw it. Simply toss it into the simmering soup and provides it a few additional minutes. You’ll comprehend it’s prepared when the gnocchi float to the highest and are comfortable and pillowy.
You can too discover gluten-free gnocchi at many grocery shops. With gluten-free, you simply wish to cook dinner it in accordance with the bundle instructions earlier than including it in on the very finish.
Vegetable Add-Ins
This soup is tremendous versatile relating to veggies. When you’ve received extras available or simply wish to increase the diet, listed below are some simple add-in choices:
Mushrooms: Add 1 cup of sliced mushrooms with the carrots and celery. Sauté till softened and calmly browned, about 5 to 7 minutes.
Corn: Stir in 1 cup of frozen or canned corn while you add the peas and gnocchi. No additional cook dinner time wanted.
Child Spinach: Add 2 cups of contemporary child spinach on the very finish, proper earlier than serving. It’ll wilt in only a minute or two.
Diced Potatoes: Peel and cube 1 medium russet or Yukon gold potato into small cubes. Add it in with the broth so it has time to melt, about quarter-hour of simmering ought to do it.
Inexperienced Beans: Use 1 cup of chopped contemporary or frozen inexperienced beans. Add them with the carrots and celery so that they cook dinner by way of and keep tender-crisp.
Simply watch out to not overload the pot. About 2 cups of additional veggies whole is an efficient rule of thumb to maintain the steadiness proper.


Adjusting Thickness
This soup is designed to be creamy and hearty, however you’ll be able to completely tweak the feel based mostly on the way you prefer it:
To Make It Thicker: If you’d like a thicker soup, whisk collectively 1 tablespoon of cornstarch with 2 tablespoons of chilly water. Stir it into the soup after including the cream and gnocchi, and simmer for an additional 2 to three minutes till thickened. You can too cut back the broth by 1 cup in the beginning for a naturally thicker outcome.
To Make It Thinner: In case your soup seems thicker than you’d like (particularly if it sat for a bit), simply stir in an additional 1 to 2 cups of rooster broth or water. Add slightly at a time till it’s the consistency you need, then heat it by way of earlier than serving.
Storage & Reheating
Refrigerate leftovers in an hermetic container for as much as 4 days. Because it sits, the soup will proceed to thicken.
Reheat on the stovetop over medium-low warmth, stirring often, till warmed by way of. If it’s too thick, simply add couple of tablespoons of rooster broth or water. You can too microwave particular person parts in 30-second increments, stirring in between.
Freeze: This soup isn’t one of the best candidate for freezing as soon as it’s totally made. The cream and gnocchi don’t maintain up properly and may flip grainy or mushy after thawing.
If you wish to freeze it, right here’s the workaround: Make the recipe up by way of the simmering step earlier than including the cream, peas, and gnocchi. Let it cool fully, then switch to a freezer-safe container and freeze for as much as 3 months.
While you’re able to take pleasure in it, thaw it within the fridge in a single day, then convey it again to a simmer on the range. Stir within the cream, gnocchi, and peas and cook dinner for the ultimate 5 minutes as directed.

