Creamy.

Dreamy.

Mashed potatoes.

This recipe combines the collective knowledge of a whole bunch of suggestions and methods to excellent your creamy mashed potatoes.

So, let’s get into it!

Disclaimer: A number of the hyperlinks on this put up could also be affiliate hyperlinks for merchandise I take advantage of and love. For those who make a purchase order after clicking a type of hyperlinks, I could earn a small affiliate fee, maybe sufficient to purchase some additional gochujang or gochugaru 🙂

Why Creamy Mashed Potatoes?

I really feel such as you actually can’t have a “sides” part in your weblog with out addressing probably the most iconically American aspect dish–mashed potatoes. I may very well be biased, right here. I’m a self-professed potato-phile and I’ve beloved mashed potatoes since I used to be just a little lady. Of all of the aspect dishes on the Thanksgiving desk, it was the one aspect dish I’d all the time return for no less than thrice.

However having tried making my very own 12 months after 12 months, I’ve found that there are a number of methods to make them style, nicely, TERRIBLE. They arrive out gummy or mealy or watery or pasty. As soon as, I made an entire batch that by some means turned bitter.

The reality is, the perfect creamy mashed potatoes of your life aren’t arduous to make. However, they’re additionally not arduous to screw up!

So, herein, you’ll find all my suggestions for making the BEST creamy mashed potatoes you’ll ever eat!

Tips about Making the BEST Creamy Mashed Potatoes.

Tip #1: Choose the Proper Spuds.

Use a mixture of each russet potatoes (which have extra starch) and Yukon gold (which maximizes creaminess) to create the right mix in your creamy mashed potatoes.

Tip #2: Keep away from the Mistaken Taters.

Keep away from utilizing waxier potatoes, like pink potatoes, as they have an inclination to carry extra moisture and run the chance of changing into gummy (no!).

Tip #3: Bake These Infants.

Bake your potatoes as an alternative of boiling them. Not solely will this require much less effort, it can guarantee much less moisture to attain fluffy and non-gummy mashed potatoes.

Tip #4: Heat Your Liquids.

All of your liquids—the butter and milk—should be heat or, on the very least, at room temperature. Chilly liquids will stop your potatoes from absorbing their pretty flavors.

Tip #5: Pre-coat with Butter.

Coat your potatoes in butter earlier than including your milk to make them additional buttery!

Tip #6: Get the Proper Gear.

Utilizing a ricer or a meals mill will stop you from overworking the potatoes (which can make them gummy and gross!).

Key Components and Notes on Substitutions for Creamy Mashed Potatoes Recipe.

This creamy mashed potatoes recipe solely requires simple elements with a couple of twists. Let’s check out every of the important thing elements:

Russet and Yukon Gold Potatoes.

No, you can not make creamy mashed potatoes with out potatoes. Sure, I do know there are recipes made with cauliflower masquerading as this iconic aspect dish, however these are mashed cauliflower–completely scrumptious, however not mashed potatoes.

As I point out above in Tip #1, what you need is a mixture of each russet and Yukon gold for these creamy mashed potatoes. The russets are very starchy and can assist to maintain the mashed potatoes fluffy and light-weight. The Yukon golds are just a little waxier (although not almost as waxy because the reds), and can maximize creaminess.

For those who don’t have a mixture, you possibly can merely go along with all russets or all Yukon golds.

Roasted Garlic.

I would like these creamy mashed potatoes to actually detonate a taste bomb in your mouth and which means we want garlic. A complete head of garlic. We’re going to roast the garlic within the oven together with the potatoes, in order that they’ll be mushy and candy. For those who don’t like garlic (what’s mistaken with you…?), you possibly can skip the garlic.

Milk.

You possibly can’t have creamy mashed potatoes with out some type of milk. I take advantage of Chobani’s additional creamy oat milk for this recipe, which I discover to be very creamy. You possibly can, after all, use no matter number of milk you have got, although I’d keep away from one thing as skinny as almond milk. My favorites are all the time oat milk and soy milk in terms of all my recipes. You too can substitute with heavy cream, if you would like; however, it’s costlier and more durable to seek out (for us dairy-free people) and oat milk does the trick anyway!

Contemporary Herbs.

This creamy mashed potatoes recipe requires contemporary rosemary and thyme. They may make your mashed potatoes jaw-droppingly scrumptious, so I’d not skip this half. The flavors that these herbs present will make anybody who tastes these creamy mashed potatoes go, “WHOA THOSE ARE AMAZING.”

For those who can’t discover rosemary and thyme, you can even go along with sage and/or oregano. I’d not attempt to substitute with dried herbs as doing so will make it arduous to attain optimum creaminess.

Butter.

You want butter to make creamy mashed potatoes. I take advantage of Earth Stability’s butter sticks, however Nation Crock additionally makes a fantastic dairy-free butter.

Are you able to substitute with additional virgin olive oil? Sure. Each the flavour and fats content material of additional virgin olive oil makes it substitution candidate for butter. You too can strive utilizing avocado oil. Nonetheless, it gained’t be fairly the identical in terms of taste.

Miso.

Miso provides simply the correct amount of umami and savoriness to those creamy mashed potatoes, whereas additionally heightening the creaminess. For those who don’t have miso or don’t need to use miso, you possibly can all the time skip this ingredient.

White Pepper.

Along with the usual salt and black pepper, these creamy mashed potatoes additionally name for just a little white pepper. White pepper has a extra refined warmth than its darker half, black pepper. It additionally lends a little bit of brightness to your mashed potatoes (that’s what I’ve all the time discovered, no less than). For those who don’t have white pepper, you possibly can merely skip it.

Step-by-Step Directions for Making Creamy Mashed Potatoes.

As I’ve talked about, these creamy mashed potatoes are very simple and are available collectively fairly shortly. So, let’s get to it!

Step 1.

Preheat oven to 450° F. Utilizing a fork, poke holes into your potatoes earlier than wrapping them in foil and inserting them on a baking sheet. Minimize the garlic head in half, drizzle the open halves with olive oil, and in addition wrap in foil and place on baking sheet. Place the potatoes and garlic within the oven for about 60 to 70 minutes, till potatoes are all fork tender.

Step 2.

About half-hour earlier than the potatoes are completed, add milk to a small sauce pot, along with rosemary and thyme, over a low warmth. Let the milk get heat over low warmth, ensuring that it by no means involves a boil.

Step 3.

As soon as the potatoes are completed, scoop out all of the flesh and place by way of a meals mill or ricer. Equally, place the roasted garlic by way of a meals mill or a ricer.

Step 4.

Add miso and melted butter and stir in till the potatoes are evenly coated. Then, add the nice and cozy milk (fish out the herbs earlier than doing so!). Stir till potatoes are creamy and flavorful. Season with salt, white pepper, and black pepper, to style.

Step 5.

Scoop out into a big bowl and use the again of your spoon to create a small divot into the center. Add one other tablespoon of unmelted butter to the divot and sprinkle with thyme leaves simply earlier than serving.

Need Extra Vacation Recipes?

1

2

3

Creamy Vegan Mac ‘n Cheese Casserole.

The creamiest most scrumptious mac ‘n cheese of your life!!

Try this recipe

4

5

6

Ceaselessly Requested Questions.

Recipe Card.

Creamy Mashed Potatoes

Joanne Molinaro

The very best mashed potatoes ever!

Prep Time 20 minutes minutes

Cook dinner Time 1 hour hr 10 minutes minutes

Course Aspect Dish

Delicacies American

• 2 lbs russet potatoes
• 2 lbs Yukon gold potatoes
• 1 head garlic
• 1 tbsp additional virgin olive oil
• 1 1/2 cup milk (I used oat milk)
• 2 sprigs contemporary rosemary
• 2 sprigs contemporary thyme, plus extra for garnish
• 2 tbsp miso
• 1/3 cup butter, melted and dropped at room temperature
• 1 tsp sea salt
• 1 tsp white pepper
• 1 tsp black pepper
• 1 tbsp not melted butter

• Preheat oven to 450° F. Utilizing a fork, poke holes into your potatoes earlier than wrapping them in foil and inserting them on a baking sheet. Minimize the garlic head in half, drizzle the open halves with olive oil, and in addition wrap in foil and place on baking sheet. Place the potatoes and garlic within the oven for about 60 to 70 minutes, till potatoes are all fork tender.

• About half-hour earlier than the potatoes are completed, add milk to a small sauce pot, along with rosemary and thyme, over a low warmth. Let the milk get heat over low warmth, ensuring that it by no means involves a boil.

• As soon as the potatoes are completed, scoop out all of the flesh and place by way of a meals mill or ricer. Equally, place the roasted garlic by way of a meals mill or a ricer.

• Add miso and melted butter and stir in till the potatoes are evenly coated. Then, add the nice and cozy milk (fish out the herbs earlier than doing so!). Stir till potatoes are creamy and flavorful. Season with salt, white pepper, and black pepper, to style.

• Scoop out into a big bowl and use the again of your spoon to create a small divot into the center. Add one other tablespoon of unmelted butter to the divot and sprinkle with thyme leaves simply earlier than serving.

Key phrase creamy mashed potatoes

Did you want this recipe? In that case, please depart a score and share it!