Monday, June 9, 2025
HomeFoodThe Secret to the Greatest Beef Empanadas? It is Not Beef

The Secret to the Greatest Beef Empanadas? It is Not Beef



Why It Works

  • Pulsing the jerky in a blender pulverizes it rapidly and completely.
  • Cooking a comparatively great amount of onions slowly brings out their sweetness, which enhances the salty meat.

Regardless of the place you end up in Argentina, there’s in all probability an empanada close by. Certainly one of my favourite methods to get to know a spot once I’m touring across the nation is by sampling the native model of those ubiquitous snacks. Whereas an Argentinian empanada would possibly sound fully bizarre—a easy wheat dough filled with meat, most frequently beef, baked or fried—it is a bite-size expression of the land and its individuals.

For a lot of the nation’s historical past, Argentines have trusted two staples: wheat flour and beef. Up till the Eighties, the common individual’s annual beef consumption hovered between eighty and ninety kilograms, a lot of it probably eaten with a chunk of bread to sop up the juices. So it is sensible that the nation’s hottest handheld meals, believed to have been launched to this a part of the continent by Spanish colonists 5 centuries in the past, is a mirrored image of the nation’s two kitchen fundamentals. 

In February, I spent two weeks touring throughout the northeastern state of Chaco, transferring from the capital of Resistencia to El Impenetrable Nationwide Park, with lengthy layovers within the bus stations of small cities alongside the way in which. Within the village of Miraflores, I dipped right into a comedor in the hunt for sizzling espresso and a candy pastry and ended up with empanadas and a chilly soda. At 10 a.m., empanadas had been the one factor that was able to serve and there was only a single accessible filling: Carne al cuchillo, beef minimize into small cubes and stewed, which I wasn’t allowed to order till its maker, Francisco Villagrán, confirmed up and turned on the deep fryer.

“The trick to an excellent empanada chaqueña,” he instructed me, “isn’t the meat however slightly the onions.” For each kilogram of meat, he sautés twice as a lot onion in a slowly cooked sofrito, the sweetness balanced out with the addition of a beneficiant quantity of white pepper, paprika, and no matter else is readily available, often dried herbs like parsley or oregano. 

Whereas persistence for the proper sofrito often is the trick to a correct empanada chaqueña, meat is one other defining attribute. Within the northern reaches of the nation, the place temperatures climb excessive and remoted rural communities subsist largely off their lands, charqui, a dried beef jerky, is a well-liked and sensible filling.

Miraflores is separated from Paraje La Armonia, a rural neighborhood that sits on the entrance of the park, by sixty kilometers and a bumpy filth street that may solely be traversed in a pickup truck when the climate’s dry. A handful of households stay there in nearly full isolation: there’s no web, electrical energy is unreliable, and what they do not or cannot develop on their very own land is supplied by meals bought from neighbors or introduced in by family and friends members who stay in small cities with supermarkets.

I had traveled to La Armonía to satisfy Estela Castellano, who spent two afternoons instructing me to make conventional dishes of this dry, densely forested space, and the very first thing that I seen was a skinny piece of pulpa, or the higher thigh of the cow, doubled over like a sheet on a clothesline, drying into charqui beneath the new solar. Her husband, Estebán, sat within the shade of his lined patio with a slingshot to chase away the birds. 

Charqui is a meat preservation method that dates again to pre-Colombian occasions, which unfold from Peru down by means of the Andes Mountains. Meat is minimize skinny as a sheet and rubbed with salt, then hung in direct daylight to dry within the warmth of summer time. In Northern Argentina, it’s most frequently rehydrated in stews and used to stuff tamales and empanadas. In El Impenetrable, charqui isn’t simply consumed out of respect for custom; it is nonetheless as pragmatic as ever. 

Estela was flattered that I needed to study her recipes. Quiet and perceptive, she shared bits of knowledge solely when she sensed that I wanted it. Earlier than we received began she warned me with a smile: “I don’t have something written down so pay shut consideration.”

Critical Eats / Kevin Vaughn


I did simply that and realized rapidly that each technical question (“What number of grams of tallow per cup of flour?”) can be met with a real, “I don’t know,” significantly when it got here to my questions on her empanada dough. Estela’s recipes don’t stay on paper; slightly, they stay in her muscle reminiscence, within the odor of tallow combining with flour, in the way in which that the dough softens round your fingers, within the slight yellow colour of her completed masa, which felt extra cloud-like than clean in my palmsall of those sensory particulars had been clues to constructing the correct dough. 

Whereas Estela chopped onions and bell peppers with a serrated desk knife, Estebán pounded the charqui in a mortar and pestle carved out of a skinny tree log that was as tall as my hips. Estebán seasons his charqui with nothing greater than salt and some days value of daylight. It was sturdy and tore aside in lengthy strings with seen motes of gristle and fats. And but, after what felt like an eternity of watching him hammering away with the mortar, the jerky turned mushy and stringy, with a consistency like cotton sweet.

As I watched Estela make the empanada filling, I noticed that she agreed with what Francisco had proclaimed again in Miraflores: onions had been an important ingredient. Besides as a substitute of double the load of the jerky, Estela used a close to three-to-one ratio of uncooked onion, cooked sluggish in considerable oil till they had been mushy and glistened with a honeyed hue. In a area outlined by intense, unforgivable climate (the day we cooked collectively, the temperature hovered round 100ºF) onion is a reliable yr spherical staple. However its considerable use didn’t really feel merely sensible. The sofrito method was essential to constructing out the flavour: The sweetness and caramel notes of the onions had been excellent enhances to the fatty jerky, the acidic tomato sauce, and the recent inexperienced herbs and beneficiant spoonfuls of white pepper, which was nearly as vital because the onions.

When Estela pulled the filling off the stovetop, the leathery jerky had been reworked and the filling had the feel of finely pulled meat, the proper medium for the remainder of her arsenal of ordinary however masterfully chosen pantry staples—paprika, chopped hard-boiled eggs, cooked-down bell peppers, oregano, recent chives and thyme—packing every chunk with sweetness, acidity, spice, and herby aromatics. Every thing was folded into mushy empanada discs and cooked in as excessive a warmth because the oven might obtain till the dough turned sandy brown and flaky. I ate practically a dozen between sips of a chilly glass of lager. After I left, Estela handed me a tupper with one other six that hardly survived the remainder of the afternoon.

Selecting the Proper Jerky

Again at house, I used to be fearful that I wouldn’t have the ability to recreate that excellent afternoon. First got here the daunting job of selecting a jerky. I settled on Buenos Aires-brand Charquiqui, which makes use of meat minimize from the hind legs of younger grass-fed cows. The meat is massaged with a secret flavoring mix, though proprietor Pablo Rojas revealed to me that among the many precept flavors are natural honey, lime peels, and recent pineapple and celery juice. The charqui has a delicate citrusy-sweet taste profile with grassy, fatty notes that burst from the meat with every chunk, just like Estebán’s jerky. Charquiqui’s jerky can be barely moist with a noticeable layer of fats, each of which jogged my memory of Estebán’s handmade jerky and made tearing it into shreds simpler.

I initially tried to interrupt the meat down with a picket mortar and pestle, and rapidly realized that the dimensions and depth of the bowl had been unsuitable for the duty, and it was going to take a very long time and a whole lot of elbow grease to create the cottony texture I used to be searching for. Estebán’s pestle and mortar allowed him to hammer the jerky slightly than merely grind, breaking down the meat fiber with considerably extra power. I attempted as a substitute to pulse batches of lengthy shreds in a blender earlier than kicking up the pace to excessive. It labored. After a minute, I had fluffy, cottony jerky.

Given the variations in salt ranges of assorted manufacturers of jerky, it is clever to watch out as you season the filling for these empanadas. Relying on the jerky you employ, it’s possible you’ll want little additional salt as soon as the filling is completed.

Taking Benefit of Pantry Staples

Estela’s selections for greens, herbs, and spices had been completely on level however she assured me that tiny particulars change from yr to yr relying on what grows properly within the yard. “The jerky, onions, and hard-boiled eggs are required to make an empanada de charqui however the remaining will be made up relying on what you could have readily available,” Estela assured me.

This yr, a drought compounded by document heatwaves destroyed her small herb and vegetable backyard: Solely her chives survived. Fairly than recent herbs and complete spices, she used dried thyme and oregano and floor white pepper. I opted to make use of recent thyme and freshly floor white pepper and a smoked paprika so as to add an additional layer of smokiness.

As for the fats within the dough recipe, the tallow that Estela used had a comparatively impartial taste. I attempted to seek out one thing comparable as soon as I returned to Buenos Aires and started my very own recipe testing, however regardless of the abundance of beef in Argentina, I failed to seek out any tallow that wasn’t overly beefy. As a substitute, I shifted to utilizing butter, which I discovered managed to make a dough that was akin to Estela’s. When you do need to use tallow (or pork lard), use two-thirds the quantity of butter by weight as known as for within the beneath recipe.

A Dozen Empanadas, Only for Me

All through the preparation, I took Estela’s lead and cooked patiently, taking note of my senses greater than my mock up of her recipe. I added water slowly, taking note of how the dough softened in my palms and, when it got here time to roll them out, I didn’t fear about excellent circles.

Likewise, I paid shut consideration to constructing taste and listening to how the jerky sounded on the stovetop. I let the onions cook dinner sluggish, practically 20 minutes on very low warmth, and slightly than Estela’s estimated half cup of tomato sauce, I added an additional cup once I might hear the meat scorching earlier than the bell peppers had cooked by means of.

The ultimate outcome took me again to that afternoon, hanging out for the day with Estela and Estebán on their patio. I couldn’t cease myself from consuming a dozen—the signal of an excellent empanada. I want I might’ve despatched Estela what was left in a tupperware.

July 2022

The Secret to the Greatest Beef Empanadas? It is Not Beef



Prepare dinner Mode
(Preserve display awake)

For the Dough:

  • 2 1/2 cups (400g) all-purpose flour

  • 5 tablespoons (70g) room temperature unsalted butter, minimize into 1/2-inch cubes, plus extra for greasing the baking sheet

  • 2/3 cup (170m) lukewarm water

  • 1 tablespoon plus 3/4 teaspoon (11g) Diamond Crystal kosher salt; if utilizing desk salt use half as a lot by quantity or similar weight

For the Filling:

  • 1/2 pound (250g) beef jerky (see notice), torn into strips

  • 3 medium yellow onions (650g), chopped

  • 3 tablespoons (45ml) vegetable or different impartial oil

  • 1 1/2 cups (225ml) raw tomato pureé or passata

  • 1 medium crimson bell pepper (6 ounces; 180g), stemmed, seeded, and diced

  • 1 medium inexperienced bell pepper (6 ounces; 180g), stemmed, seeded, and diced

  • 1 teaspoon freshly floor white pepper

  • 1 teaspoon smoked paprika

  • 1 teaspoon recent thyme, leaves picked and chopped

  • 1 teaspoon dried oregano

  • 3 massive eggshardboiled, peeled, and diced

  • Handful of recent chives (20g), finely minced

  • Kosher salt

  1. For the Dough: In a medium mixing bowl, whisk collectively flour and salt. Add the butter to the flour and salt combination and toss to coat. Utilizing clear palms, pinch the butter items flat. Step by step add water and blend together with your palms till a barely sticky dough types. Switch dough to a clear work floor and knead dough till it turns into mushy and clean, about 5 minutes. Place dough in a plastic bag or wrap in plastic and let relaxation at room temperature for at the least Half-hour and as much as 1 hour.

    Critical Eats / Kevin Vaughn


  2. In the meantime, for the Filling: Working in 3 separate batches, place jerky in a blender and pulse a number of occasions to interrupt it up. Flip blender to excessive pace and mix till jerky is mushy, mild, and fluffy, like coarse cotton sweet, about 1 minute. Put aside.

    Critical Eats / Kevin Vaughn


  3. In a 5-quart Dutch oven, warmth oil over medium-high warmth till shimmering. Add onion and stir till evenly coated with oil. Scale back warmth to medium-low and cook dinner, stirring often to keep away from scorching, till onion is mushy and darkish brown in colour, about 20-Half-hour.

    Critical Eats / Kevin Vaughn


  4. Enhance warmth to medium, stir in beef jerky and cook dinner, stirring, for 1 minute. Stir in tomato purée, inexperienced bell pepper, crimson bell pepper, white pepper, smoked paprika, thyme, and oregano, carry to a simmer, then scale back warmth to take care of a simmer and cook dinner, stirring often, till tomato sauce has diminished fully and bell peppers have softened, about quarter-hour. If tomato sauce reduces an excessive amount of earlier than bell peppers have cooked by means of fully, add water a tablespoon or two at a time to keep away from scorching till pepper absolutely soften. Switch combination to a medium bowl and let cool. As soon as cool, stir in hard-boiled eggs and chives. Season with salt, if wanted. Put aside.

    Critical Eats / Kevin Vaughn


  5. To Make the Empanada: Regulate oven rack to center place and preheat oven to 500°F (260°C). Grease a rimmed baking sheet with butter. Utilizing the palms of your palms, roll rested dough right into a roughly 9-inch (24cm) cylinder. Reduce into 24 items, roughly 30g every; each bit must be concerning the measurement of your thumb. Cowl the items with plastic wrap or a moist material to stop drying out. Working with one piece at a time, form each bit of dough right into a flattened disc. Utilizing a rolling pin, roll the dough disc right into a roughly 4-inch (10cm) circle.

    Critical Eats / Kevin Vaughn


  6. Holding the dough disc within the palm of 1 hand, place a tablespoon (roughly 35g) of meat filling within the middle of the disc. Fold the dough over the filling to surround it, forming a half-moon form; use your fingers to softly seal the perimeters collectively whereas ensuring to push out any air bubbles.

    Critical Eats / Kevin Vaughn


  7. Fold the correct nook of empanada in in the direction of the middle and pinch to crimp. Working from that nook, proceed crimping with a slight twisting movement to type factors alongside the sting, in order that the empanada seems like a half-sun with rays, then end by folding the left nook in and pinching to crimp; make sure you work the dough gently to keep away from air bubbles or tearing. Place fashioned empanada on ready baking sheet and repeat course of with remaining empanada discs and filling.

    Critical Eats / Kevin Vaughn


  8. Bake empanadas till dough is frivolously browned on the outside, about 25 minutes. Take away empanadas from oven and let cool for 10 to fifteen minutes earlier than serving.

    Critical Eats / Kevin Vaughn


Particular Gear

Kitchen scale, rolling pin, baking sheet, blender.

Notes

You have to to regulate the quantity of salt you add relying on the saltiness of the meat jerky you employ. The perfect kind of beef jerky to make use of is sun-dried jerky, like carne seca or machaca, and I encourage you to attempt to hunt down sun-dried jerkies made in small batches.

This dough doesn’t must be chilled. Doña Estela doesn’t relaxation her dough earlier than rolling out empanada discs. The opposite cooks I ready empanadas with, Doña Graciela and Doña Zulma, rested their dough lined within the shade outdoor, for Half-hour to 1 hour in 80-95ºF warmth.

RELATED ARTICLES

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Most Popular

Recent Comments