Thursday, June 11, 2026
HomeDessertsHome made Butterfinger Recipe: Copycat Sweet Bars

Home made Butterfinger Recipe: Copycat Sweet Bars


The answer to all that leftover sweet corn…

Homemade Butterfingers made with leftover candy corn!

Hello! Butterfingers anybody?! I’ve been OBSESSED with this do-it-yourself butterfinger recipe for longer than I care to confess, and I genuinely assume it’s one of the vital enjoyable, most satisfying issues you may make with a bag of leftover sweet corn. Sure — sweet corn! Should you’ve obtained a candy tooth and a pile of post-Halloween sweet simply sitting in your counter gazing you, that is your signal. Let’s make some magic! 🎃🍫

I’ve obtained greater than sufficient leftover sweet corn to make do-it-yourself Butterfingers for everybody. Yep. You learn that proper. Sweet corn = do-it-yourself Butterfingers. Nicely, truly: sweet corn + peanut butter + chocolate = do-it-yourself butterfinger sweet bars. That’s it! Three easy components. Actually, I’ve been that means to make these for the longest time each single Halloween season, and one thing at all times will get in the way in which — normally my husband, who’s a licensed sweet corn junkie and can’t be trusted round a full bag.

So, in fact… I made this WAY earlier than there was a chance for sweet corn leftovers. In any other case, I won’t have had the prospect with my husband round! Should you love peanut butter as a lot as I do, you’ve GOT to take a look at my Peanut Butter Truffles Recipe and my Peanut Butter Sweet Corn Rice Krispies Treats — each are completely dreamy and deplete Halloween sweet like a dream!

What Makes This Home made Butterfinger Recipe So Nice

Are you able to REALLY make a REAL Butterfinger with sweet corn and peanut butter? Actually? Not precisely — and I need to be upfront about that! The feel is absolutely chewy, extra like taffy. It will get somewhat nearer to the true factor in case you refrigerate it, nevertheless it’s nonetheless not precisely the identical as the unique sweet bar. The flavour is shut although, and actually, how can something made with peanut butter and sweet corn style dangerous? One of the best half is that these use easy components you most likely have already got, with no bizarre components or thriller fillers you may’t pronounce. That alone is a big win for this do-it-yourself sweet state of affairs!

Of the umpteen recipes I scoped out earlier than making these, they ALL claimed to be identical to a Butterfinger. After which when mine got here out chewy as an alternative of crunchy, I used to be genuinely irritated that not ONE of these websites talked about that the within isn’t crunchy like a Butterfinger. I imply… that looks as if a reasonably important a part of one among our favourite childhood candies! So I’m telling you now — chewy, not crunchy. Nonetheless completely scrumptious. Don’t say I didn’t warn you! 😄

Homemade Butterfingers made with leftover candy corn!Homemade Butterfingers made with leftover candy corn!

Substances and Tools You’ll Want

The ingredient listing right here is superbly brief. You’ll want your leftover sweet corn, creamy or crunchy peanut butter (I like a crunchy peanut butter filling state of affairs personally!), and chocolate chips for coating. To soften sweet corn, you simply pop it in a microwave-safe bowl briefly bursts — it will get shiny and clean actually quick. You then stir within the peanut butter combination and press every part right into a parchment paper-lined 9×13 inch baking pan. That’s mainly the whole course of! For tools, seize a small bowl for mixing, a wood spoon, and a dish towel to deal with the new pan. If you wish to go the stovetop route, a small saucepan works completely too.

One factor I actually love about this recipe is that it doesn’t require a sweet thermometer or a double boiler technique or something intimidating like that. No scorching sugar combination to panic over, no medium-high warmth drama, no granulated sugar boiling in a cup water state of affairs in a medium saucepot — simply soften, combine, press, and chill. It’s the best method to make do-it-yourself sweet bars with none fuss! And once you soften chocolate chips excessive and let it arrange within the fridge, you get these beautiful large bars that look completely legit. 🍫✨

Homemade Butterfingers made with leftover candy corn!Homemade Butterfingers made with leftover candy corn!

Suggestions for the Finest Home made Butterfingers

A couple of issues I’ve realized from making these a number of occasions! First, line your pan with wax paper or parchment paper and ensure it goes up the edges — this makes lifting the entire slab out SO a lot simpler. When you’ve pressed the peanut combination in and the melted chocolate layer is on high, faucet the pan gently on a heat-proof work floor to clean every part out. Let it come to room temperature briefly earlier than transferring it to the fridge. When it’s absolutely set, raise it out utilizing the parchment paper and lower it into sweet items or candy bars — no matter measurement makes you cheerful! Use an oven mitt if the pan continues to be heat from the chocolate step. Retailer leftovers in a sealed container or hermetic container at room temperature or within the fridge for as much as every week.

If you wish to get further cute with it, pop the sweet items right into a ziplock bag and crush them up with a rolling pin for a enjoyable topping on ice cream or brownies! You can too sprinkle some salt flakes excessive of the chocolate earlier than it units — that basic mixture of candy and salty is completely chef’s kiss. The variety of servings you get depends upon how massive you chop your bars, however a typical pan yields about 16–20 items, which is a good way to feed a crowd or fill a deal with field! 🧂🍬

Vegan and Allergy-Pleasant Swaps

Okay, so in case you’re into plant-based dwelling or simply making an attempt to make a wholesome do-it-yourself butterfinger model, I’ve excellent news! These vegan butterfingers are an incredible possibility for anybody avoiding dairy or animal merchandise — simply use dairy-free chocolate chips and double-check your sweet corn model. For individuals who want a nut-free swap, you need to use sunflower seed butter or pumpkin seed butter instead of peanut butter — each work superbly in this sort of texture-forward sweet recipe. Simply notice that if allergic reactions are a priority, at all times examine for traces of nuts in your packaging. Sunflower seed butter provides these a barely completely different taste, nevertheless it’s nonetheless a super-easy candy deal with recipe that sweet lovers will devour! And in case you’re inquisitive about extra scrumptious vegan recipes and superb meals for plant-based dwelling, try assets like wfpb recipes communities — a lot inspiration on the market for scrumptious candy treats with out compromise. You can too seize a duplicate of the plantyou cookbook or use the plantyou planner and interactive meal planner platform for superb weekly menu concepts and weekly dishes constructed round healthful, scrumptious meals! 🌱

A Observe on the “Different” Butterfinger Technique

You could have seen the extra elaborate do-it-yourself model that entails corn syrup, maple syrup, and an precise sweet thermometer — the place you mix granulated sugar, corn syrup, and a cup water in a small saucepan, cook dinner it to the arduous crack stage over medium-high warmth, then fold in a vanilla-baking soda combination and a maple combine earlier than stirring in peanut butter. That course of provides you extra of that crunchy cornflake mixture-style texture (some variations truly fold in half of the cornflakes at this stage for further crunch, utilizing the contents of the cornflakes field to imitate the flaky layers of the unique sweet bar). You pour all of it into a really massive metallic bowl, fold it round, then press it right into a reusable liner or parchment-lined pan. You possibly can modify the form of the tin to get large bars or smaller bite-sized sweet items. Some people additionally add vanilla extract and coconut oil to the chocolate coating for further gloss. That technique is legit and produces one thing a lot nearer to butterfinger bars from the shop — nevertheless it’s additionally a LOT extra concerned. The sweet corn model is our shortcut do-it-yourself model, and for a super-easy candy deal with recipe that requires zero savoury cooking abilities, it genuinely delivers! Whether or not you employ corn syrup or sweet corn, these are a favourite deal with this time of 12 months. 🍂

Make These With Your Children This Halloween Season

Can we discuss what a enjoyable bonding exercise that is?! Making do-it-yourself butterfingers along with your youngsters is genuinely one among my favourite issues to do that time of 12 months. The complete course of is hands-on in one of the best ways — melting, stirring, urgent, ready (okay, the ready is tough!), after which reducing into these beautiful candy bars collectively. It’s an interactive expertise that makes the tip consequence style even higher, I promise. My youngsters love being accountable for urgent the peanut butter combination into the pan and drizzling the melted chocolate on high. Whole chaos, complete pleasure. Additionally, it’s a good way to make use of up sweet which may in any other case simply sit in a bowl till February. And for much more Halloween inspiration, try Swanky’s BEST Halloween Desserts and my Finest Swanky Halloween Desserts Recipes — there are SO many good issues over there! And in case you’re a peanut butter obsessive like me, you completely have to strive my Final Peanut Butter Popcorn Recipe subsequent — it’s one among my all-time favourite candy-adjacent snacks. This type of state of affairs is strictly why I like Halloween baking season a lot. 🎃❤️

Regardless of the feel not being 100% similar to the unique — this recipe is scrumptious. And enjoyable. And really easy! It does style remarkably much like a (chewy) Butterfinger, particularly contemplating the easy components getting used. Hit the shops right this moment and purchase out all of that clearance sweet corn (or deplete the stash of leftovers I’m positive your husband isn’t gobbling up with reckless abandon) so you may make these yummy Butterfinger copycats! And truthfully? That is a kind of do-it-yourself sweet conditions the place you’ll marvel why you didn’t strive it sooner. Go make them. Proper now. You must! 🙌🍫

Proper this manner for extra methods to make use of up that leftover Halloween sweet…

Peanut Butter Snickers Cookies

PB Snickers CookiesPB Snickers Cookies

55+ Recipes to Use Halloween Sweet

55+ Halloween Candy Recipes55+ Halloween Candy Recipes
How to Make Homemade Butterfingers using Candy CornHow to Make Homemade Butterfingers using Candy Corn
How one can Make Home made Butterfingers utilizing Sweet Corn – nice for utilizing up leftover sweet corn at Halloween!
Homemade Butterfingers made with leftover candy corn!Homemade Butterfingers made with leftover candy corn!

Home made Butterfingers

Sweet corn and creamy peanut butter melted collectively and coated in chocolate to create a chewy, scrumptious copycat Butterfinger sweet bar.

Substances

  • 3 cups of sweet corn
  • 1.5 cups of creamy peanut butter
  • Milk chocolate

Directions

1. Combine sweet corn and peanut butter

2. Stir and microwave 30 seconds at a time till melted collectively

3. Line an 8x8in dish with foil

4. Unfold the combination into the dish

5. Let is cool at room temperature for 1 hour

6. Slice into small bars

7. Soften chocolate for dips

8. Smother bars into chocolate, set them on a tray and let the chocolate settle. Take pleasure in!

RELATED ARTICLES

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Most Popular

Recent Comments