Ice Cream Sandwich Cake – (Simply 3 Components!)

By Street Food Spectacle

July 1, 2026

0

4

This straightforward ice cream sandwich cake is tremendous fast to make at dwelling, with simply 3 components!

Why you’ll love this ice cream sandwich cake

The frozen dessert is enjoyable to arrange and ideal for birthdays, sleepovers, summer season pool events, or Fourth of July barbecues with household and buddies.
All the components ought to be available at your native grocery retailer.
And in contrast to different comparable ice cream cake recipes, this one requires no cream cheese, condensed milk, heavy cream, or chocolate pudding combine.
It’s easy to customise and create completely different flavors, and everybody will get so as to add their very own favourite toppings!

Readers additionally love these Apple Pie Egg Rolls

Step-by-step recipe video

Key components

Ice cream sandwiches – To fill a normal 9×13 inch baking pan, you’ll need about nineteen full dimension vanilla ice cream sandwiches. Any model will do, together with gluten free, sugar free, or dairy free and vegan ice cream sandwiches. Mini ice cream sandwiches are additionally effective to make use of.

Whipped topping – I like to recommend full fats frozen whipped topping, as a result of I’ve not examined the recipe with low fats or fats free varieties. As soon as once more, keto and dairy free alternate options to Cool Whip work as nicely.

When you can’t discover whipped topping, substitute an equal quantity of ice cream. Be happy to make use of any taste ice cream. I’ve made this DIY summer season dessert previously with vanilla, chocolate, and cookie dough ice cream, and it’s at all times scrumptious.

Variations and topping concepts

Purple, white, and blue – For a simple patriotic ice cream sandwich cake, beautify the dessert with recent blueberries, raspberries or sliced strawberries, and non-obligatory fruit jam between every layer. When you’re feeling fancy, organize the berries within the form of a flag. Prime every slice with festive vacation sprinkles and a cherry if desired.

Cookies and cream – Sprinkle one cup of crushed OREO cookies on high of every ice cream sandwich layer. Add chocolate syrup and extra OREOs on the finish for presentation.

Nutella – Unfold a layer of retailer purchased or Do-it-yourself Nutella in between every layer. Sprinkle toasted hazelnuts over the completed ice cream cake.

Caramel fudge – This model is for true dessert lovers with a candy tooth. Drizzle one 12 ounce jar of caramel sauce and one 12 ounce jar of sizzling fudge sauce over the primary and second layers of whipped topping. Garnish with chopped peanuts, pecans, M&M’s, Butterfingers, Snickers, sliced bananas, or chocolate chips.

Darkish chocolate – Use chocolate ice cream sandwiches as a substitute of vanilla. Add the non-obligatory chocolate fudge sauce, and high with chocolate cookies or chocolate peanut butter cups.

Desire a wholesome model? Do this Yogurt Breakfast Cheesecake

Red White Blue Ice Cream Sandwich Dessert

Tips on how to make an ice cream sandwich cake

Unwrap the ice cream sandwiches forward of time and retailer them within the freezer. This makes meeting a breeze when you’re prepared to arrange the no bake cake.
Thaw one container of whipped topping for 3 to 4 hours within the fridge so it is going to be simpler to unfold. For finest outcomes, don’t miss on the counter or microwave, because it may end in soupy cream.
Prepare a single layer of ice cream sandwiches in an oblong 9×13 inch pan, slicing one sandwich in half in order that they fill your complete backside of the pan. (See the images and video beneath for a visible tutorial.)
Unfold one container of whipped topping evenly over the layer of frozen sandwiches. If utilizing the chocolate fudge sauce and caramel sauce, drizzle them on at the moment too.
Subsequent, add a second layer of ice cream sandwiches. Then cowl the pan and freeze for an hour or extra. When getting ready the home made ice cream sandwich cake for a celebration, I prefer to comply with steps one by 5 the day earlier than after which freeze in a single day. This implies much less work to do on the day of the occasion.
Just a few hours upfront, thaw the second container of whipped topping within the fridge. Unfold it over the frozen cake simply earlier than serving.
Garnish with crumbled cookies, chocolate syrup, or your toppings of alternative. This time, I selected to brighten the cake with patriotic recent berries. Alternatively, depart the cake plain and let visitors every garnish their very own slices nevertheless they select.
Slice and serve the ice cream pie on dessert plates with forks or spoons.

Ceaselessly requested questions

Can I substitute actual whipped cream?

I don’t advocate swapping ready heavy whipping cream for the Cool Whip type frozen topping. Do-it-yourself dairy whipped cream lacks stabilizers and should separate. Nonetheless, you should utilize ice cream or nondairy ice cream, like this Coconut Ice Cream.

How do I retailer the recipe?

Instantly freeze any leftover slices so they don’t soften. Retailer leftovers in a tightly lined container within the freezer for as much as one week.

Can I flip this into an eight inch cake?

Completely! The recipe as written yields an enormous ice cream sandwich cake that may serve as much as twenty 5 folks. In case you are solely making it to your circle of relatives or a small gathering, merely lower all components in half to fill a smaller pan. In different phrases, purchase only one tub of whipped topping and ten ice cream sandwiches (or sufficient to fill the underside of an eight inch pan).

Does it work with different ice cream sandwich flavors?

Use any taste you would like. The cake is incredible with chocolate, mint chocolate chip, or Neapolitan ice cream sandwiches. Or substitute the sandwiches with chocolate chip cookie sandwiches to make a Chipwich ice cream cake as a substitute.

No Bake Ice Cream Sandwich Cake Party Dessert

1. Unwrap all the ice cream sandwiches forward of time. Thaw the containers of whipped topping within the fridge (not the counter or microwave) for 3 hours prior to make use of. This step makes them simpler to unfold.
2. Cowl the underside of a 9×13 inch pan with a single layer of ice cream sandwiches. You could want to chop the sandwiches to suit. (See video beneath for a useful visible.)
3. Unfold one container of the whipped topping over the ice cream sandwich layer. If utilizing sizzling fudge sauce, drizzle it on now as nicely.
4. Add a second layer of ice cream sandwiches, then cowl the pan and freeze a minimum of 1 hour or in a single day.
5. When able to serve, unfold a second thawed container of frozen whipped topping on high of all the things. Garnish as desired with cookies, chocolate chips, patriotic berries, or cake toppings of your alternative. You possibly can slice and serve with out toppings if most well-liked, letting visitors beautify their very own slices.
6. Retailer leftover ice cream sandwich cake lined within the freezer for as much as every week.