Step 1: Prep the Pan
Line a 9×9-inch baking dish with parchment paper, leaving some overhang on the edges so you possibly can simply elevate all the things out later. This makes slicing a lot simpler as soon as the sandwiches are frozen.
Step 2: Construct the Base
Organize half of the Pop-Tarts in an excellent layer on the underside of the pan. If utilizing store-bought, attempt to discover Unfrosted Pop-Tarts.
The Pop-Tarts actually make these sandwiches. They keep gentle and chewy straight from the freezer and style so good with the creamy ice cream. Plus, they’re simply enjoyable!
Step 3: Swirl the Ice Cream
Gently swirl collectively the vanilla ice cream, strawberry ice cream, and jam. You are able to do this instantly over the Pop-Tarts or in a bowl. Don’t overmix—you need these thick strawberry ribbons all through.
If the ice cream is simply too agency, let it sit out for a couple of minutes first. Softer ice cream spreads far more simply and retains the layers good and even.
Step 4: Assemble the Sandwich
Unfold the swirled ice cream over the Pop-Tarts in an excellent layer, then high with the remaining Pop-Tarts to create one massive ice cream sandwich.
It may get a bit of messy right here, however that’s a part of the enjoyable. Embrace the imperfect, semi-homemade vibe—and don’t overlook to sneak a couple of spoonfuls of the ice cream alongside the way in which!
Step 5: Freeze Till Agency
Cowl and freeze till fully agency, a minimum of 4 hours, however in a single day is even higher should you can wait. The firmer they’re, the better they’ll slice.
These are good to make forward for summer time weekends so everybody can seize one straight from the freezer.
Step 6: Make the Frosting
Whisk collectively the powdered sugar, vanilla, and scorching milk till clean and spreadable. Begin with much less milk, then slowly add extra till the frosting is thick however simple to unfold.
That is what offers them that basic selfmade Pop-Tart really feel—candy, easy, and so good with the chilly ice cream.
Step 7: Frost and Embellish
Unfold the frosting over the frozen sandwiches, then instantly high with sprinkles earlier than it units.
The sprinkles make these additional enjoyable and immediately convey you again to childhood. The extra colourful, the higher!
Step 8: Freeze Once more
Return the pan to the freezer for one more 1–2 hours, simply till the frosting is about and the sandwiches are simple to slice cleanly.
Step 9: Slice and Serve
Raise the slab out of the pan and lower into rectangles or squares. Retailer within the freezer in order that they’re prepared anytime.
