This submit might comprise references to merchandise from a number of of our advertisers. Oh Candy Basil might obtain compensation whenever you click on on hyperlinks to such merchandise.
In the event you love thick chocolate chip cookies with gooey facilities and crisp edges, this recipe is for you. Impressed by the well-known Levain Bakery cookies, these outsized, bakery-style cookies are tall, wealthy, and require two palms to eat with out the journey to NYC.
After standing in line at Levain and later discovering comparable jumbo cookies nearer to dwelling, I knew I needed to recreate them in my very own kitchen minus the nuts (no thanks!) and specialty components. After in depth testing (and a lot of cookies), this recipe delivers all the pieces individuals love about Levain-style cookies: peak, chew, and complete indulgence made with on a regular basis components.
What Makes These Cookies So Thick?
These cookies keep thick due to a number of key methods that stop them from spreading an excessive amount of within the oven.
First, the ratio of components is designed to assist a tall cookie. The dough incorporates loads of flour and simply the correct amount of fats, which supplies the cookies construction whereas nonetheless holding them delicate and gooey within the middle. I’ll clarify extra under.
Second, the recipe makes use of each baking soda and baking powder. Baking soda reacts with the brown sugar to create raise, whereas baking powder offers the cookies an additional enhance in order that they rise as a substitute of spreading flat.
One other necessary issue is the massive dough balls. Every cookie is made with about 6 ounces of dough, which permits the surface to set whereas the within stays thick and delicate.
Lastly, chilling the dough helps solidify the butter earlier than baking. This slows down how shortly the cookies unfold within the oven, serving to them preserve their tall, bakery-style form.
The result’s precisely what we’re going for: thick, gooey chocolate chip cookies with crisp edges and delicate facilities similar to the well-known bakery variations.
Testing Thick Chocolate Chip Cookies (What Truly Issues)
Testing these cookies was no joke! I experimented with totally different flours, fat, and leavening combos to determine precisely what creates that tall, bakery-style cookie with a delicate, gooey middle.
Right here’s what I discovered…
Flour: All-Function vs Cake Flour
Many individuals swear that cake flour is the key to thick cookies, so I examined batches with each all-purpose flour and a mixture of all-purpose and cake flour.
Cake flour does create a barely lighter texture, however the cookies had been nearly too delicate and cake-like for our style. We most popular the construction and chew from all-purpose flour, which supplies the cookies that traditional bakery cookie texture with out requiring a particular journey to the shop. No cake flour wanted!
In the event you’d prefer to experiment, you’ll be able to substitute ¼ of the flour with cake flour for a barely softer cookie.
Fats: Butter vs Cream Cheese
Butter is the standard fats in chocolate chip cookies, however it incorporates some water that evaporates throughout baking. Very similar to the flour, I examined batches with all butter and different batches with a small quantity of cream cheese to extend the fats content material and create a barely richer texture.
Each variations had been scrumptious, however the distinction was refined so we desire all butter. In the event you’d prefer to attempt it:
The best way to Substitute Cream Cheese for Butter
- Exchange 2–3 tablespoons of butter with softened cream cheese
- Add 2 additional tablespoons of flour to maintain the dough balanced
It provides a slight tang and richness, however we nonetheless desire the all-butter model for traditional taste.
Leavening: Baking Soda vs Baking Powder
Leavening additionally performs a giant position in how tall cookies bake up.
- Baking soda reacts with acidic components (like brown sugar) to create carbon dioxide bubbles that assist cookies rise.
- Baking powder incorporates baking soda plus an acid, permitting it to create raise even with out further acidic components.
As a result of these cookies are additional thick, baking soda alone didn’t present sufficient raise. Utilizing each baking soda and baking powder gave the cookies the construction and peak we wished.
Consider baking powder because the spotter serving to raise a heavier weight—it offers the cookies the additional rise they should keep thick and bakery-style.
Elements You’ll Want
Let’s dig into all of the components you’ll need. They really aren’t too totally different out of your typical chocolate chip cookies so right here is your grocery listing:
- All Function Flour: Gives the construction for the cookies whereas holding them chewy and durable.
- Baking Soda: Helps the cookies unfold simply sufficient whereas contributing to browning and taste.
- Baking Powder: Provides these thick cookies additional raise in order that they bake tall as a substitute of flat.
- Cornstarch: Retains the cookies thick and delicate, creating a young, melt-in-your-mouth texture.
- Salt: Balances the sweetness and enhances the wealthy chocolate taste.
- Unsalted Butter: Provides richness and taste whereas serving to create crisp edges and delicate facilities.
- Brown Sugar: Provides moisture and chewiness, giving the cookies their signature delicate inside.
- Egg: Binds the dough collectively and provides construction and richness.
- Vanilla: Enhances the general taste and brings heat to the cookie dough.
- Semi Candy Chocolate Chips: Present the right stability of sweetness and wealthy chocolate taste all through each chunk.
The measurements for every ingredient will be discovered within the recipe card down under.
The best way to Make Thick Chocolate Chip Cookies
You make these cookies similar to every other, however on the finish, I take advantage of a meals scale to weigh the dough into large balls. Listed here are the essential steps:
- Dry Elements: Whisk all of the dry components in a medium bowl.
- Moist Elements: Beat the butter and sugars in a stand mixer at medium velocity till fluffy. Then add the egg after which the vanilla. Beat till clean.
- Mix: Flip off the mixer and scrape the perimeters. Add the dry components and blend on low velocity till you’ll be able to flip it as much as medium with out exploding flour all over. Add the chocolate chips and blend them in.
- Chill: Chill the dough within the fridge for at the very least 20 minutes, as much as in a single day.
- Prep: Preheat the oven to 350℉.
- Weigh: Use a meals scale to measure out 6 ounces of dough. Roll it right into a ball and place it on a baking sheet lined with parchment.
- Bake: Bake for 10-11 minutes. Place on a cooling rack and eat them as quickly as you’ll be able to! I like to recommend letting them sit for at the very least 10 minutes if you happen to can. So onerous!
Why These Cookies Use Cornstarch
Cornstarch is a bit of trick that helps create thick, bakery-style cookies with a delicate middle. It really works by softening the proteins within the flour, which retains the cookies tender whereas nonetheless permitting them to carry their form.
In a recipe for additional thick cookies, that’s particularly necessary. Cornstarch helps the cookies keep tall and delicate as a substitute of spreading skinny.
How Huge Ought to Thick Chocolate Chip Cookies Be?
For actually thick bakery-style cookies, use 6-ounce dough balls. It might sound enormous, however that measurement is the key to getting the tall, gooey-centered cookies everybody loves.
I resisted weighing cookie dough for years, however utilizing a kitchen scale makes a giant distinction. When every dough ball weighs the identical, the cookies bake evenly and are available out completely each time with no underbaked facilities or overbaked edges.
In order for you cookies that look and bake like the enormous bakery-style ones, 6 ounces of dough per cookie is the candy spot. It’s huge, however belief me, and it’s precisely what makes these cookies prove good.
Professional Ideas for Levain-Model Cookies
Just a few small methods make a giant distinction in holding these cookies thick and bakery-style.
- Begin with butter that’s softened however nonetheless cool to the contact. It ought to go away a fingerprint when pressed however not really feel heat. Butter that’s too delicate may cause the cookies to unfold, whereas butter that’s too chilly gained’t cream correctly with the sugar.
- Subsequent, cream the butter and sugars for two–3 minutes till mild and fluffy. This helps create construction within the dough so the cookies rise correctly as a substitute of flattening.
- Two different components assist give these cookies their signature thickness. Cornstarch retains the cookies delicate whereas stopping them from spreading an excessive amount of, and beneficiant add-ins like chocolate chips (and nuts if you happen to like them) add quantity to the dough, which naturally helps the cookies keep taller as they bake.
These easy steps are the key to cookies that bake up thick, delicate, and gooey within the middle each time.
Storage, Freezing & Make-Forward Ideas
To retailer the cookies, allow them to cool utterly after which retailer them in an hermetic container at room temperature. They may preserve for 2-3 weeks. You may preserve them within the fridge for even longer.
To freeze cookies, once more cool utterly, then place in a single layer on a cookie sheet and freeze for two hours. Switch cookies to a freezer bag and retailer within the freezer for as much as 3 months.
Make these cookies as much as per week forward of time utilizing the storage instruction above. You can too make the dough, type it into balls, after which retailer both within the fridge or freezer. Bake as written within the directions including a number of additional minutes if the dough balls are frozen.
Why Didn’t Mine Keep Thick?
In case your cookies unfold an excessive amount of, considered one of these widespread points is often the perpetrator:
Butter was too heat.
Butter must be delicate however nonetheless barely cool. If it’s overly delicate or melted, the cookies will unfold.
Dough wasn’t chilled.
Chilling the dough for 20–half-hour helps solidify the fats and retains the cookies thicker whereas baking.
Dough balls had been too small.
These cookies are designed to be massive 6-ounce dough balls. Smaller cookies unfold extra and gained’t bake up as thick.
Flour was measured incorrectly.
Too little flour results in spreading. Spoon flour into the measuring cup and stage it, or weigh it for greatest outcomes.
Heat baking sheets.
At all times place dough on cool baking sheets so the butter doesn’t soften too shortly within the oven.
They’re the thick chocolate chip cookies that goals are made from! Barely crunchy on the surface, gooey on the within, thick and chewy, and simply what a chocolate chip cookie recipe must be! Till I make it again to NYC once more, I’ll be making these Levain copycat cookies at dwelling to carry me over!
Extra Copycat Dessert Recipes:
Now Watch This Video Tutorial…
